About
Community
Bad Ideas
Drugs
Ego
Erotica
Fringe
Society
Technology
register | bbs | search | rss | faq | about
meet up | add to del.icio.us | digg it
Go Back   Community > Society > Cunning Linguists
Register FAQ Members List Calendar Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read

Cunning Linguists Languages and their use. What languages do you speak and why? What do words really mean? Can you say things in one language that you can't say in another? Should there be a national language? How many languages should a person know and what are they?

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1   Add K Scott to your ignore list  
Old 2008-07-18, 12:46
K Scott K Scott is offline
Regular
 
The Midwest Send a message via AIM to K Scott
Default Is a lie a fact or an opinion?

It's my understanding that any statement can be classified as a fact or an opinion. But what about lies? Is there a category that they belong in? For instance, the sentence "The sun is blue." It's presented in the form of a fact but it isn't true, so what category similar to the categories 'facts' and 'opinions' would lies belong? Are they just called untrue statements?

This question might sound dumb but its just hard to word it.
Reply With Quote
  #2   Add BSK to your ignore list  
Old 2008-07-18, 14:51
BSK BSK is online now
Regular
 
Send a message via AIM to BSK
Default Re: Is a lie a fact or an opinion?

ex mere negativis nihil sequitur
Reply With Quote
  #3   Add Darkshock to your ignore list  
Old 2008-07-19, 03:01
Darkshock Darkshock is offline
New Arrival
 
Default Re: Is a lie a fact or an opinion?

The "fact or opinion" classification depends on how it is said or worded.

"The sun is blue" would be classified as a fact because of its wording. Just because it is classified as a fact doesn't mean it has to be true.

Hopefully that clears it up for you.
Reply With Quote
  #4   Add bignose888 to your ignore list  
Old 2008-07-19, 21:26
bignose888 bignose888 is offline
New Arrival
 
Default Re: Is a lie a fact or an opinion?

Wait a minute. A fact is something that IS true, something that actually exists, or something that can be verified according to an established standard of evaluation.

An opinion is a person's ideas and thoughts towards something. So if he says "The sun is blue", he thinks the sun is blue, but of course this isn't true.

If suddenly the sun turns blue, then it isn't an opinion anymore but a fact. Fact's can't be wrong.
Reply With Quote
  #5   Add iamalemur to your ignore list  
Old 2008-07-19, 21:35
iamalemur iamalemur is offline
Regular
 
England
Default Re: Is a lie a fact or an opinion?

I guess there's a distinction between fact, and opinion or deliberate falsehood expressed as fact..
Reply With Quote
  #6   Add Stuuuuuuu to your ignore list  
Old 2008-07-20, 06:56
Stuuuuuuu Stuuuuuuu is offline
Regular
 
Default Re: Is a lie a fact or an opinion?

^ and misconception... If I think the sun is blue, that's not my opinion, it's what I believe to be fact, even though it is false.

Therefore, "the sun is blue" isn't a fact, opinion but a falsehood (be it deliberate or accidental.
Reply With Quote
  #7   Add K Scott to your ignore list  
Old 2008-07-20, 08:54
K Scott K Scott is offline
Regular
 
The Midwest Send a message via AIM to K Scott
Default Re: Is a lie a fact or an opinion?

So basicly we can conclude that a sentence in the form of a fact that is not true is not a fact or an opinion, but a falsehood, right?
Reply With Quote
  #8   Add BSK to your ignore list  
Old 2008-07-20, 10:09
BSK BSK is online now
Regular
 
Send a message via AIM to BSK
Default Re: Is a lie a fact or an opinion?

no ..
Reply With Quote
  #9   Add Hare_Geist to your ignore list  
Old 2008-07-20, 13:00
Hare_Geist Hare_Geist is offline
Moderator
 
Default Re: Is a lie a fact or an opinion?

We say that a declaration is a lie when the person who declares it believes it to be false, and declares it with the intention of using it to hide the truth from someone. A lie is thereby itself a classification, a division within the notion of intentionality, and hence you are looking in the wrong place when you try to subsume it under fact or opinion. For the concept of lying is not concerned with the factuality of the content of declarative sentences, but with what lies behind them being declared in the first place.
Reply With Quote
  #10   Add BSK to your ignore list  
Old 2008-07-21, 08:11
BSK BSK is online now
Regular
 
Send a message via AIM to BSK
Default Re: Is a lie a fact or an opinion?

the sentence "the sun is blue" is without any other context nothing but a declaration. anything else implies more information ..
Reply With Quote
 #11 
Old 2008-07-21, 16:47
Moderator
 
Northern VA
Default Re: Is a lie a fact or an opinion?

What if you cannot confirm a fact? Is it a fact then? For example, the pirahá have concept of numbers. They have the words one, two, and many. Researchers for years have been trying to teach them to count but the strange nature of their language just doesn't allow it(they are not retarded, they just speak a very restrictive language that alters the way your brain thinks) so if you show them 5 balls in your hand, and state that you have 5 balls, is it a fact? To them you just have more than "one" ball. 5, 8, 12, 67, it's all irrelevant.
 #12 
Old 2008-07-23, 21:46
JustAnotherAsshole JustAnotherAsshole is offline
Regular
 
Default Re: Is a lie a fact or an opinion?

A lie can be a false opinion or a false fact.

Fact Example: The holocaust didn't happen.

Opinion Example: Gandhi and Mother Teresa were assholes.

As long as it's not true, it's a lie.
 #13 
Old 2008-07-30, 20:03
Regular
 
Default Re: Is a lie a fact or an opinion?

a fact is defined as something that is true, something that actually exists, or something that can be verified according to an established standard of evaluation.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fact

An opinion is a person's ideas and thoughts towards something. It is an assessment, judgment or evaluation of something. An opinion is not a fact, because opinions are either not falsifiable, or the opinion has not been proven or verified. If it later becomes proven or verified, it is no longer an opinion, but a fact.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opinion

I assume that a lie falls into the opinion category.
 #14 
Old 2008-08-02, 16:48
Blanko Blanko is offline
Regular
 
Default Re: Is a lie a fact or an opinion?

i guess that it could depend on whether you know the lie to be untrue or not. to use your example, if you say the sky is blue, believing it to be true, i guess that it is merely a false fact, but if you are trying to fool someone (i.e. knowing the sun isn't blue but trying to make someone believe that it is) then it could be seen as more of an opinion because your trying to subjectively say that the blueness of the sun outweighs its yellowness or whatever color. or maybe its all in how you word it (as someone pointed out), either way good topic/question...
 #15 
Old 2008-08-03, 09:27
Moderator
 
Default Re: Is a lie a fact or an opinion?

blanko can we please leave out suggestions which add other facts not mentioned? look at the sentence without any other information and then decide what it is.
 #16 
Old 2008-08-05, 18:35
Nietzche Nietzche is offline
Regular
 
Default Re: Is a lie a fact or an opinion?

back to the topic at hand:

a lie is simply the intention of misdirecting your attention from the truth. But there are rules involved:

to lie you need to know the truth, since lies are opposites of truth

bullshit on the other hand considers neither truth or lie, just a way to get by. It ignores the rules of the game completely.

read "on bullshit" by frank herbert, its like a 15 min read. really tiny book
 #17 
Old 2008-08-05, 18:55
Regular
 
http://tinyurl.com/28ozhm
Default Re: Is a lie a fact or an opinion?

God doesn't exist.
God exists.

Both are facts, regardless of whether they are true or not.
 #18 
Old 2008-08-07, 16:11
nincumpoop nincumpoop is offline
Regular
 
Default Re: Is a lie a fact or an opinion?

It's a 'False fact' if you would like, No such thing exists to my knowledge, But that is the way i would describe it.
 #19 
Old 2008-08-14, 18:52
Moderator
 
Wasilla, Alaska
Default Re: Is a lie a fact or an opinion?

Why a lie is a lie has to do with iuntent, and a lie may relate to fact or opinion.

A cop may say did you do this, and you say no when in fact you did. That is a lie regarding a fact.

If you want to suck up to your boss, who is a Bushite, you may state an opinion favorable to Bush to curry favor, when in truth you despise the vapid war criminal, thus making a stated opinion a lie.
Reply

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Show Printable Version
Email this Page Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Linear Mode
Hybrid Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode
Threaded Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is Off
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump

 
To the best of our knowledge, the text on this page may be freely reproduced and distributed.
 

totse.com certificate signatures
 
 
About | Community | Bad Ideas | Drugs | Ego | Erotica | Fringe | Society | Technology
Hot Topics