About
Community
Bad Ideas
Drugs
Ego
Erotica
Fringe
Society
Technology
register | bbs | search | rss | faq | about
meet up | add to del.icio.us | digg it
Go Back   Community > Society > My God Can Beat the Shit Out of Your God
Register FAQ Members List Calendar Today's Posts

My God Can Beat the Shit Out of Your God For discussing any and all religious viewpoints. Intolerance will not be tolerated. Keeping your sense of humor is required. Posting messages about theological paradoxes is encouraged.

 
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1   Add shuu to your ignore list  
Old 2008-06-02, 07:21
shuu shuu is offline
Regular
 
Default if god didn't exist...

...why would he let millions of people believe in him, worship him and dedicated their lives to him in vain?
Reply With Quote
  #2   Add gadzooks to your ignore list  
Old 2008-06-02, 07:22
gadzooks gadzooks is offline
Regular
 
Canada
Question Re: if god didn't exist...

../../www.esreality.com/files/placeimages/2007/55173-lolwut.jpg
Reply With Quote
  #3   Add Mufasa09 to your ignore list  
Old 2008-06-02, 08:10
Mufasa09 Mufasa09 is offline
Regular
 
Elysium
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

Brilliant!
Reply With Quote
  #4   Add pot_prince to your ignore list  
Old 2008-06-02, 11:00
pot_prince pot_prince is offline
Regular
 
Newcastle Australia
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

not existing does have the unfortunate side effect of not being able to stop people worshipping you.

i'll tell you what though, if you worshipped me and i didn't exist I'D sure come and tell you to stop . . . . once i figured out how to exist . . . . . although then maybe you SHOULD worship me with me existing and all
Reply With Quote
  #5   Add parkus to your ignore list  
Old 2008-06-02, 11:01
parkus parkus is offline
Regular
 
Up north, UK.
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

Quote:
Originally Posted by pot_prince View Post
not existing does have the unfortunate side effect of not being able to stop people worshipping you.
Aw, someone had to ruin it.
Reply With Quote
 #6 
Old 2008-06-02, 11:04
Regular
 
Candyland <3
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

Ahahaha.
<3
 #7 
Old 2008-06-02, 15:44
Regular
 
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

A flawless victory of Shuu's part. Motion to archive.
 #8 
Old 2008-06-02, 18:30
Moderator
 
Wasilla, Alaska
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

Satan--the devil--does not exist, nor do heaven or hell. Yet millions of people believe in those things.

Truth is not something to be determined by popular vote. Truth just is, and can neither be proven nor disproven.
 #9 
Old 2008-06-02, 19:00
willancs willancs is offline
Regular
 
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

Truth just is, and can neither be proven nor disproven.

This is an assertion. How do you know?
 #10 
Old 2008-06-02, 19:37
Moderator
 
Wasilla, Alaska
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

This is an assertion. How do you know?

Okay, let's take a simple and mundane example. I had a bowl of Life cereal for breakfast this morning. I know this is true--but I cannot prove this assertion, nor can anyone else disprove it.
 #11 
Old 2008-06-02, 19:52
Regular
 
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

Okay, let's take a simple and mundane example. I had a bowl of Life cereal for breakfast this morning. I know this is true--but I cannot prove this assertion, nor can anyone else disprove it.

*Gets stool sample from Arms later that afternoon, and sends to lab to be analyzed.

Now we can prove or disprove your assertion.
 #12 
Old 2008-06-02, 22:48
sum42dood sum42dood is offline
Regular
 
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

*Gets stool sample from Arms later that afternoon, and sends to lab to be analyzed.

Now we can prove or disprove your assertion.

prove that the stool sample came from arms
prove that whatever you find in there is life cereal
prove that the sample even exists
  #13   Add shuu to your ignore list  
Old 2008-06-03, 07:37
shuu shuu is offline
Regular
 
Exclamation Re: if god didn't exist...

Quote:
Originally Posted by pot_prince View Post
not existing does have the unfortunate side effect of not being able to stop people worshipping you.
he's god, he can do anything
Reply With Quote
 #14 
Old 2008-06-03, 07:40
gadzooks gadzooks is offline
Regular
 
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

he's god, he can do anything

Even spark his own existence! EEK!
  #15   Add thizz all day to your ignore list  
Old 2008-06-03, 18:26
thizz all day thizz all day is offline
Regular
 
East Bay; Capitol of Meth
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

Because majority of humans seem to have this belief that they are a complete different entity then anything else in this universe =\ and that we came from the heavens. We just evolved more then other things but are just as closely related to everything else in this universe and are just apart of a huge circle.

Most people when having no where else to go need some kind of hope, they create a god so they have something to rely on and tell their conscience well there is hope, there's 'god'. By telling themselves that it forces them to keep hope and be able to get through whatever the fuck it is so they claim it was god who helped them when it was just themselves doing it subconsciencly.

I guess you can claim our brain is god, my belief of 'god' is everything in this universe. God is a not a him, her, it's not a person, an animal, a spirit but god is everything that exists.

Do you know how many other planets there are that contains some sort of life form? Millions. We are nothing special. Besides your reasons for believing in god is incredibly poor.

People are afraid of dieing and don't wanna believe when we die, we die. That's it there's nothing left, no after life no nothing. Just like anything else on this planet that dies, once it's gone it's gone. I agree it does make me feel better if I believed in going to a different place when I die and that my life wont be over completely but that isn't the way.
Reply With Quote
 #16 
Old 2008-06-03, 18:39
blackfox26 blackfox26 is offline
Regular
 
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

Quote:
Originally Posted by ArmsMerchant
Satan--the devil--does not exist, nor do heaven or hell. Yet millions of people believe in those things.

Truth is not something to be determined by popular vote. Truth just is, and can neither be proven nor disproven.


Truth is an illusion of the mind. Truth,like reality, depends upon the individual.
  #17   Add harry_hardcore_hoedown to your ignore list  
Old 2008-06-04, 08:57
harry_hardcore_hoedown harry_hardcore_hoedown is offline
Regular
 
Perth, Australia
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

Quote:
Originally Posted by thizz all day View Post
God is a not a him, her, it's not a person, an animal, a spirit but god is everything that exists.
Oh, you're into that new-age bullshit. Good luck with that.
Reply With Quote
  #18   Add thizz all day to your ignore list  
Old 2008-06-05, 04:41
thizz all day thizz all day is offline
Regular
 
East Bay; Capitol of Meth
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

Quote:
Originally Posted by harry_hardcore_hoedown View Post
Oh, you're into that new-age bullshit. Good luck with that.
New age? That's just my own belief... If others believe that I'd like to meet them.

Honestly, stupid fucks that believe god is a thought processing being is such bulshit. I have never read a bigger fairy tale then the bible and the commandments? Get the fuck out of here, that's just common sense.

Why doesn't god speak to anyone nowadays? Wheres all the 'magical' like people/things; moses, burning bushes, people turning to stone and whatever the fuck else the bible bulshits about? A senior citizen built a fucking super tanker by himself and collected every single species, now what the fuck.

The more gods a civilation has, the dumber they were. They created gods to explain what they couldn't explain/understand themselves. Now with pretty much only 1 god left which is the 'creator of all things', is only because we have yet to understand or discover how all of this came about... But we are more and more, finding out that humans are nothing more important or better then anything else in this universe.
Reply With Quote
  #19   Add ArmsMerchant to your ignore list  
Old 2008-06-05, 19:33
ArmsMerchant ArmsMerchant is offline
Moderator
 
Wasilla, Alaska
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

Quote:
Originally Posted by harry_hardcore_hoedown View Post
Oh, you're into that new-age bullshit. Good luck with that.
That idea is hardly New Age, much less bullshit.

Among many others, the Sufi Muslims realize it.
__________________
"Love is infallible; it has no errors, for all errors are the want of love." -- William Law
"The astrolabe of the mysteries of God is Love." -- Rumi
Reply With Quote
  #20   Add harry_hardcore_hoedown to your ignore list  
Old 2008-06-06, 03:52
harry_hardcore_hoedown harry_hardcore_hoedown is offline
Regular
 
Perth, Australia
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

Quote:
Originally Posted by ArmsMerchant View Post
That idea is hardly New Age, much less bullshit.

Among many others, the Sufi Muslims realize it.
Good for them. This concept of God doesn't really make him much of a god. My dictionary defines 'god' as "a supernatural being, who is worshipped as the controller of some part of the universe or some aspect of life in the world or is the personification of some force". Note the 'personification' part. What is the value in worshipping the personification of a force? Should we worship gravity?
Reply With Quote
 #21 
Old 2008-06-06, 06:26
Regular
 
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

Even spark his own existence! EEK!

by definition, nothing can be impossible for god.
 #22 
Old 2008-06-06, 06:30
gadzooks gadzooks is offline
Regular
 
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

by definition, nothing can be impossible for god.

But god has to exist in the first place for these rules to apply...
 #23 
Old 2008-06-06, 20:05
Regular
 
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

Truth is an illusion of the mind. Truth,like reality, depends upon the individual.

So I only have 23 pairs of chromosomes according to myself? So to someone else, I may only have 2 pairs? I think you are mistaking Truth for belief or perception. The same with reality. Reality is that objective in-itself that the individual perceives. Yes our perceptions may be different, but they do not change what is objective reality. This is to say, you may see money as green, and I see it as grey (I'm colorblind). That doesn't change the wavelengths that are bouncing off money, it only means that my eyes perceive them differently (dysfunctionally by intersubjective standards). Reality <> Perception
 #24 
Old 2008-06-06, 20:50
Regular
 
San Lorenzo
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

Because we can only percieve reality subjectively, how can we know it objectively?
 #25 
Old 2008-06-07, 04:22
Regular
 
Perth, Australia
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

So I only have 23 pairs of chromosomes according to myself?

Do you actually believe that?
 #26 
Old 2008-06-07, 10:17
Regular
 
OZ
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

Good for them. This concept of God doesn't really make him much of a god. My dictionary defines 'god' as "a supernatural being, who is worshipped as the controller of some part of the universe or some aspect of life in the world or is the personification of some force". Note the 'personification' part. What is the value in worshipping the personification of a force? Should we worship gravity?

"What is the value"? If that force is 'life', and worship means serving life ...... ? Does not life manifest in personal form?
 #27 
Old 2008-06-07, 10:39
Regular
 
Perth, Australia
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

"What is the value"? If that force is 'life', and worship means serving life ...... ? Does not life manifest in personal form?

Life isn't a force and this isn't Star Wars. Get over it. 'Serving' life isn't the same as worshipping a god. It's just ignoring the actual point of a god but managing to avoid the label of 'atheist'. I could say that air is the real god, who I'm worshipping by breathing, and it wouldn't mean I have serious religious views. These people manipulate this concept and use the word 'energy', associating it with their religion to make up which sounds good, seemingly for no other reason than to give themselves the illusion of intelligence.
 #28 
Old 2008-06-07, 21:16
Regular
 
OZ
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

Life isn't a force

What is it then?

"force: 1. strength or energy, power". "Life: 1. The state or quality that distinguishes living beings from dead ones ... 13. a source of strength ..."(Source: Collins Concise Dictionary)
 #29 
Old 2008-06-08, 06:46
Regular
 
Perth, Australia
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

What is it then?

(Source: Collins Concise Dictionary)

A force is applied energy. Energy is the ability to do work. I'm talking about science, not conversational usage.
 #30 
Old 2008-06-08, 07:56
Regular
 
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

But god has to exist in the first place for these rules to apply...

not if anything is possible with god.
 #31 
Old 2008-06-08, 07:58
gadzooks gadzooks is offline
Regular
 
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

not if anything is possible with god.

Alright, fine, I guess you can say that an omnipotent being that doesn't exist can make itself exist, since it's omnipotent...

But that's just getting asinine...
  #32   Add WeaponsOMassIdiot to your ignore list  
Old 2008-06-08, 11:51
WeaponsOMassIdiot WeaponsOMassIdiot is offline
Regular
 
Buttsecks with Scissors
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

Quote:
Originally Posted by shuu View Post
...why would he let millions of people believe in him, worship him and dedicated their lives to him in vain?
Because we humans are some stupid motherfuckers?
Christ, if OJ Simpson could get off innocent, I'm sure a couple of guys could write a book that a few people believed and passed onto their negligent friends, thereby starting that shit.
Reply With Quote
 #33 
Old 2008-06-08, 23:32
Regular
 
OZ
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

A force is applied energy. Energy is the ability to do work. I'm talking about science, not conversational usage.

In that case Life is appropriate. It is applied energy, after all how could there be any ability to work without life. Life is energy!
 #34 
Old 2008-06-09, 03:22
Regular
 
Perth, Australia
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

In that case Life is appropriate. It is applied energy, after all how could there be any ability to work without life. Life is energy!

Cognitive functions and functions of organs use forces, but the cumulative biological forces of all life don't add up to one uniform force, they add up to a series of biological systems.
 #35 
Old 2008-06-09, 06:58
firekitty751 firekitty751 is offline
Regular
 
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

Truth is not something to be determined by popular vote.

Well, here in mainland America....


New age? That's just my own belief... If others believe that I'd like to meet them.


I do. It's strange, I sort of took things I knew, things I observed, and things I sensed to construct my beliefs, I guess. Suddenly I'm meeting all these people with similar beliefs, almost word for word the same.
  #36   Add shuu to your ignore list  
Old 2008-06-09, 13:06
shuu shuu is offline
Regular
 
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

Quote:
Originally Posted by WeaponsOMassIdiot View Post
I'm sure a couple of guys could write a book that a few people believed and passed onto their negligent friends, thereby starting that shit.
I'm sick of hearing shit like this. The bible isn't some fucking book that 'a bunch of guys' just decided to write for a 'pratical joke'. It is several books that started as an oral tradition, the mythology, folklore, history and legal documents of a society.
Reply With Quote
 #37 
Old 2008-06-10, 02:19
Regular
 
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

Do you actually believe that?

Believe what? That humans (normally) have 23 pairs of chromosomes?
 #38 
Old 2008-06-10, 02:21
Regular
 
Basement
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

God proved his existence when I did shrooms, but I don't believe anymore.
 #39 
Old 2008-06-10, 02:34
Regular
 
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

Quote:
Originally Posted by Obbe
Because we can only percieve reality subjectively, how can we know it objectively?


Why must individual experience block us from what we are experiencing. Are we all experiencing something that is not there? Are primary qualities not existent?
  #40   Add KikoSanchez to your ignore list  
Old 2008-06-10, 02:36
KikoSanchez KikoSanchez is offline
Regular
 
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

Quote:
Originally Posted by shuu View Post
I'm sick of hearing shit like this. The bible isn't some fucking book that 'a bunch of guys' just decided to write for a 'pratical joke'. It is several books that started as an oral tradition, the mythology, folklore, history and legal documents of a society.
Yes, but how did all these oral traditions and myths come together as the bible? And for what purpose? This is what is important.
Reply With Quote
 #41 
Old 2008-06-10, 02:39
Regular
 
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

In that case Life is appropriate. It is applied energy, after all how could there be any ability to work without life. Life is energy!

Even if I gave you that much, it does not mean that energy is life. And I thought that was what you were originally making the point of.
 #42 
Old 2008-06-10, 02:41
Regular
 
San Lorenzo
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

Why must individual experience block us from what we are experiencing.

I didn't suggest that.

Are we all experiencing something that is not there? Are primary qualities not existent?

Are we? How can you tell, when your perception is subjective?
 #43 
Old 2008-06-10, 02:43
Regular
 
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

Alright, fine, I guess you can say that an omnipotent being that doesn't exist can make itself exist, since it's omnipotent...

But that's just getting asinine...

But god is also (supposedly) perfect and to most (Anslem) perfection must entail existence. Therefore, an entity would not be god if it did not exist. To Shuu: anything may be possible within god, but if an entity does not meet the definition of god, it is not god.
 #44 
Old 2008-06-10, 02:52
Regular
 
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

I didn't suggest that.



Are we? How can you tell, when your perception is subjective?

Continuing existence and intersubjective verification. If I was not experiencing something outside of myself, then it seems these would not hold up.

Some have proposed how these (continued existence and intersubjective verification) may be possible, such as Berkeley using God's eternal perception...but that is taking on a whole new beast and even Berkeley stated that his philosophy of idealism would be inane to any reader that did not believe in god (by his definition).
 #45 
Old 2008-06-10, 02:57
Regular
 
San Lorenzo
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

Continuing existence and intersubjective verification.

Is your expereince of this verification somehow not subjective?

If I was not experiencing something outside of myself, then it seems these would not hold up.

Appearances could be deceiving.

Also, I never implied that there was no outside source of your experience. I simply questioned how you can know reality objectively, when you only percieve it subjectively.
 #46 
Old 2008-06-10, 04:55
Regular
 
Perth, Australia
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

Believe what? That humans (normally) have 23 pairs of chromosomes?

Yes. I was meant to follow your response up with some subjective reality argument, but I've forgotten what it is. I'm not arguing against the fact that humans have 23 pairs of chromosomes.
 #47 
Old 2008-06-10, 05:25
Regular
 
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

Quote:
Originally Posted by ArmsMerchant
Satan--the devil--does not exist, nor do heaven or hell. Yet millions of people believe in those things.

Truth is not something to be determined by popular vote. Truth just is, and can neither be proven nor disproven.



lol wut?

The devil does exist and he sure has succeeded at deceiving you.
 #48 
Old 2008-06-10, 19:36
Regular
 
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

Also, I never implied that there was no outside source of your experience. I simply questioned how you can know reality objectively, when you only percieve it subjectively.

Again your language seems to denote that you think subjectivity is some sort of hindrance. "when you ONLY perceive it subjectively". How else could something 'perceive' something else? The only way to define, within a system, the system's objective reality, is within the system itself. I use my own perceptions, along with all others' perceptions to come to an understanding of what is real (not only a perception) or not real (only a mental perception, with no retaining object outside of my mind) within the system. For instance, if I were on shrooms, I may have a perception of seeing a cat, but I will not be able to touch it and it will not be able to touch me, scratch me, etc and others will not verify that it is there. Individual perception is not a hindrance, but a gathering of possibility information. If you take solipsism to be true, then we are working with two different concepts of what reality is or may be defined by and we can't really move on from there.
 #49 
Old 2008-06-10, 19:42
Regular
 
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

lol wut?

The devil does exist and he sure has succeeded at deceiving you.

Orr you've been deceived on the former. Wouldn't an evil spirit deceiving your cognitions conflict with god supposedly giving us free will?
 #50 
Old 2008-06-13, 17:30
Regular
 
In ya mam.
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

Okay, let's take a simple and mundane example. I had a bowl of Life cereal for breakfast this morning. I know this is true--but I cannot prove this assertion, nor can anyone else disprove it.

You could film it...
 #51 
Old 2008-06-14, 01:11
Regular
 
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

prove that the stool sample came from arms
prove that whatever you find in there is life cereal
prove that the sample even exists

Prove your not a douche bag....

Some things are self-evident.
  #52   Add ViperX202 to your ignore list  
Old 2008-06-14, 04:02
ViperX202 ViperX202 is offline
Regular
 
laVal D-Block
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

Quote:
Originally Posted by shuu View Post
...why would he let millions of people believe in him, worship him and dedicated their lives to him in vain?
he is an answer to a unanswerable question
Reply With Quote
 #53 
Old 2008-06-15, 23:23
Regular
 
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

Prove your not a douche bag....

Some things are self-evident.

The problem is arms made a statement of: truth cannot be proven, nor disproven. Then he sidestepped an important question and gave us a tricky situation (prove he ate something that morning). But to make the point, we need something that SHOULD be easily provable or disprovable as an example, not something that would be difficult...since this is supposed to apply to all instances of truth. I think his example only may show that truth can SOMETIMES be impossible to prove or disprove...and this much is already obvious.
 #54 
Old 2008-06-16, 01:37
Regular
 
Default Re: if god didn't exist...

Truth is an illusion of the mind. Truth,like reality, depends upon the individual.

or in a more easier to understand version

truth in perception
 


Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is Off
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump

 
To the best of our knowledge, the text on this page may be freely reproduced and distributed.
 

totse.com certificate signatures
 
 
About | Community | Bad Ideas | Drugs | Ego | Erotica | Fringe | Society | Technology
Hot Topics