I told this guy on msn that I don't believe in the soul, and he replied "but nothing can be empty" and changed the subject.

What the hell does he mean by this? It sounds really stupid. Have you ever heard an argument like it?

It just doesn't make sense. Make him explain himself. I guess he believes the soul has some seat, physical or otherwise, in the body?

Theres no soul. Just like theres no good and evil.

Who says nothing can be empty? Is he talking a physical emptiness or an emotional emptiness?

Is he implying that without the soul the body is 'empty'?

How can something spiritual (soul) occupy something physical (body), anyway?

It sounds to me like he gave a very vague, ambiguous response in order to sound deep, covering up his 'empty' logic.

quote:It sounds to me like he gave a very vague, ambiguous response in order to sound deep, covering up his 'empty' logic.[/B]

Indeed.

Ha! That reminds me of this guy who used to frequent this forum - his moniker was Abrahim and the end-all of all his arguments was "The Soul is Reality" or "God is Reality".

Insist that he clarify his point, and then for shits and giggles - let us know what he said.

Makes as much sense as anything else.

Because nothing is empty.

nothing by definition is completely empty

it seems my entire philosophy revolves around entirely un-clever puns

quote:Originally posted by boozehound420:

Theres no soul. Just like theres no good and evil.

Is that right? *slits a woman's throat in front of her 5-year old son* Yay!!

quote:Originally posted by shitty wok:

Is that right? *slits a woman's throat in front of her 5-year old son* Yay!!

The Nazis saw themselves in the right, and they gassed children.

quote:Originally posted by shitty wok:

Is that right? *slits a woman's throat in front of her 5-year old son* Yay!!

Good job.

quote:Originally posted by shitty wok:

Is that right? *slits a woman's throat in front of her 5-year old son* Yay!!

Sure we could call that "evil". In our minds. As some kind of universal constant, evil does not exist. It is only a function of human conciousness. Get it?

Learn how to do astral traveling, then you will know it exists.

quote:Originally posted by your enemy:

Learn how to do astral traveling, then you will know it exists.

You don't know shit.

Ya ask me, the soul is all the electrical energy contained in the human body.

quote:Originally posted by AngryFemme:

Ha! That reminds me of this guy who used to frequent this forum - his moniker was Abrahim and the end-all of all his arguments was "The Soul is Reality" or "God is Reality".



Whatever happened to that poor little shit? His circular logic and mistaken simplicity was amusing.