If the girl says no but doesn't fight it and enjoys it/has an orgasm, is it considered rape?

Or is it considered seduction?

What is your opinion?

As long as the girl says no, it's rape.

Read your law book, pal.

Seduce-

1.To lead away from duty, accepted principles, or proper conduct.



2.To induce to engage in sex.

To entice or beguile into a desired state or position.

To win over; attract.



Rape-

1.The crime of forcing another person to submit to sex acts, especially sexual intercourse.

2.The act of seizing and carrying off by force; abduction.

3.Abusive or improper treatment; violation: a rape of justice.

quote:Originally posted by psycho_8b:

As long as the girl says no, it's rape.

Read your law book, pal.My law book says nothing of the sort. Laws are different everywhere. This controversy is usually based on the judges OPINION in court. I am asking for opinions from other people not what your country/states law may say.

I know your opinion though. I also assume you are female.

It's rape whenever SHE wants it to be rape. If she doesn't like it, she can claim rape. If it would be good for her social standing, she'll claim rape. If she's bored, she'll claim rape.

Just slap the bitch upside the head with a rock, and tie her up so she can't claim rape to anyone.

quote:Originally posted by Gus:

It's rape whenever SHE wants it to be rape. If she doesn't like it, she can claim rape. If it would be good for her social standing, she'll claim rape. If she's bored, she'll claim rape.

Just slap the bitch upside the head with a rock, and tie her up so she can't claim rape to anyone.

Always listen to the fat ugly fucks. They are THE number 1 rape experts.

quote:Originally posted by DiStOrTiOn:

Always listen to the fat ugly fucks. They are THE number 1 rape experts.

Winner for lol of the week goes to....

quote:Originally posted by You Will Die:

[QUOTE]My law book says nothing of the sort. Laws are different everywhere. This controversy is usually based on the judges OPINION in court. I am asking for opinions from other people not what your country/states law may say.

I know your opinion though. I also assume you are female.



*Looks in boxers...*

My bollocks state that I am male.

When I was in school, we had a cop come in and tell us that it is actually rape whenever a girls says no.

You might be just about to pop your cork and she can say no, which means get out of her then and there or she can legally claim rape.

Fucked up really.

And yeah...Gus has a point...I've met guys who've been hit with the rape bat.

EDIT: Spell check

[This message has been edited by psycho_8b (edited 02-03-2007).]

quote:Originally posted by You Will Die:

If the girl says no but doesn't fight it and enjoys it/has an orgasm, is it considered rape?

Or is it considered seduction?

What is your opinion?

Much guilt and confusion in victims of childhood rape or molestation from a family member or family friend or the like stems from the fact that, on a purely physical level, they take pleasure from it. It's a physical response, can't help it. So, scenario; eight-year old is molested by her father. She doesn't fight because she's scared. On a physical level it's pleasurable, despite whatever it's doing to her head. Seduction?

As long as you think it's not rape then it ain't. You would have to consider it to be rape in your own mind for it to be rape. But, in law they got you.

quote:Originally posted by You Will Die:

Seduce-

1.To lead away from duty, accepted principles, or proper conduct.



2.To induce to engage in sex.

To entice or beguile into a desired state or position.

To win over; attract.



Alright, so my beloved roofies are allowed?!!

Sweet!

quote:Originally posted by DiStOrTiOn:

Always listen to the fat ugly fucks. They are THE number 1 rape experts.

Hahaha!! You're right...

The biggest sexual organ of the female is her brain. She can't have an orgasm if her brain is not into it.

Also, it often depends on if she was putting up a fight, if the "no" was said trying to get to to change your tactics, and if there's really anything to worry about... I mean if she really considered it rape she likely would have contacted the police while the evidence was still intact.



If you're really worried, talk to her, ask her what it's about and appologize if the resounding "no" was because of something you did wrong.